Showing posts with label Relativism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Relativism. Show all posts

Sunday, November 24, 2024

Apologetics 101 - Christian Case-Making - What in the World is a Worldview?

Christian Case-Making
in a Modern World

Apologetics 101

What in the World is a Worldview? 

A worldview is a set of beliefs and practices that shape a person’s approach to the most important issues in life.  It is the interpretive lens/glasses/prism through which you see life.  It guides your life's direction and grounds your ultimate concerns and values.  A good worldview gives answers to the "Big Questions of Life". 

The Big Questions of Life

A good worldview gives answers, or guides our search.
  • What kind of God, if any, actually exists?
  • Is there anything beyond the cosmos?
  • What can be known and how can anyone know it?
  • Where did I come from?
  • Who am I ?
  • Where am I?
  • How should I live?
  • What should I consider of great worth?
  • What is humanity's fundamental problem?
  • How can humanity's problem be solved?
  • What is the meaning and direction of history?
  • Will I survive the death of my body and, if so, in what state?

Where Does Our Culture Stand?

Sadly, as we will see, most people do not even hold the foundational truths of Christianity to be true anymore. In the first national study since the 2020 pandemic, the Barna Group did a worldview survey with some surprising results. Sadly, those holding to a Christian worldview have dwindled even further.

Defining a Christian Worldview

  • Believing that absolute/objective moral truth exists and can be found in the Bible.
  • The Bible is accurate in all it teaches
  • Satan is considered to be a real being or force, not merely symbolic
  • A person cannot earn their way into Heaven by trying to be good or do good works (i.e. salvation is a gift from God)
  • Jesus Christ lived a sinless life on earth
  • God is the all-knowing, all-powerful creator of the world who still rules the universe today
  • Christians have a duty to share their faith in Christ with other people.

Some Surprising Results (as of 2023)

  • While 68% of Americans still self-identified as Christians
    • Only 4% of all American adults have a biblical worldview. Barna calls this an Integrated Disciple.
    • Only 14% of all American adults even hold to a "substantial number of beliefs and behaviors" consistent with a biblical worldview. (i.e. an Emergent Follower)
    • Most Americans (82%) generally believe and act in ways that are distinct from biblical teaching. (i.e. a World Citizen)
  • Virtually every demographic category has seen significant declines, including "born-again Christians", who are down 6% to 13% holding a biblical worldview. This group is defined as believing they will go to heaven when they die, but only if they confess their sins and accept Jesus as their Savior.
  • Young people are very isolated from biblical beliefs, and unsurprisingly are the most aggressive in opposing and rejecting those principles in culture, politics, and laws. Age is a consistent factor in correlating Christian beliefs.
  • Interestingly, formal education showed little correlation to having a Christian worldview, though there was a slight trend upward for those who finished college over those who didn't.
  • With respect to politics, those who are consistently 
    • Conservative - 12% are Integrated Disciples
    • Moderate - 2% have a biblical worldview
    • Liberal/progressive - 1% have a biblical worldview

Other Common Worldviews

Obviously, the Christian worldview is not the only one.  But when looking to build yours, you need to compare and contrast it with opposing beliefs, examining the explanatory power and scope.  In other words, which one gives the best overall explanation of reality.  Others include:
  • Naturalism - the philosophical belief that everyone and everything in the universe has a physical cause and that there is no supernatural or spiritual reality.
  • Post-modernism - this is grounded in the idea that there is no objective truth, at least that can be known (i.e. it embraces subjective or relativistic truth).   It is very skeptical of grand narratives and is sometimes called the worldview that rejects all worldviews. 
  • Pantheism - the belief that God is everything and that everything is God.  We are God but don't realize it.
I hope to cover some of these, and possibly others, in depth at a later point. 

Worldview Tests

When considering, or testing, a worldview, here are a few ways to approach it:
  • Is it logically consistent? Does it make sense?
  • Does it have a good balance of explanatory power and scope, without being overly simplistic or unduly complex?
  • Does it actually match our understanding of reality, both physically and spiritually?
  • Is it testable?  Is there good evidence for or against it (even in principle)?
  • Is it liveable in actuality?  

How do I Build a Christian Worldview

Objective Truth matters. A worldview based on moral relativism has no foundation. Beliefs have a direct impact on people's behavior and lifestyles.

Discovering Truth

Truth is something we should all seek. It can be discovered or known. Unlike the Postmodern worldview, the Christian worldview holds that reality is "out there", and that truth is not simply relative to the person and that it is knowable. That does not mean, however, that we can exhaustively know everything, even if it is theoretically knowable. And we can actually come to wrong conclusions, and be wrong, so humility is required too. Before you start your search for Truth, you should ask yourself whether or not you are willing to follow the evidence wherever it leads. If your biases are such that you will reject the evidence or refuse to give honest consideration to the facts, then you might as well not bother. Regardless of their starting worldview, the truth seeker will at least consider the evidence from the viewpoint of those holding opposing views. Willful ignorance or stubborn insistence on being "right" will be a stumbling block to the search for truth. Most people would agree that all people have dignity and worth. The Christian worldview grounds this belief in the fact that we are created in the Image of God, and thus have inherent value. However, it is a fallacy to assume that because of this status, criticizing the actions of a person or challenging their deeply held beliefs is out of bounds.

Relational Discipleship

It is not good enough to just gather knowledge.  Rather we need to be trained to be able to answer the tough worldview questions for ourselves and others.  When people can connect the dots between their core beliefs, then they have a firm foundation for building out their worldview.  Integration of worldview beliefs into daily lives and interactions with others is paramount.  This is best done in a small group, or one on one, environment.

Reject Relativism

At the root, this is a worldview issue.  Embracing a relativistic view of morality greatly influences one's actions, politics, and beliefs.   Under relativism, morality is defined by either the self, groups, or the broader culture.  There can be no objective set of moral standards with regards to sexuality, personal behavior, or social interactions.

Is there any common ground?  Because this is a war of worldviews, it is hard.  If one side cannot agree with the other that truth even exists, or can be discovered, then what common truth can be agreed upon?  When the moral relativists can't even justify why human beings have intrinsic dignity, value, and worth, how can that become a grounding principle?  The Christian worldview recognizes the inherent dignity and moral worth of all human beings, from beginning of life to the end, because we are all created in the Image of God.  We are all broken because of our rebellion against our Creator, but we are valuable regardless of how we have fallen.

For example, if a definition of "justice" makes distinctions between people, especially in the Church, based principally on classes they belong to (e.g. race, sexual identity, legal status, wealth/social status, historical oppressed/oppressor groups, or other intersectionality), then it is not based on the Christian worldview and is not biblical justice.  This view of identity is not compatible with the biblical worldview.  All people in the Church need to be held to the same biblical standards of morality, and exceptions should not be made based on their identity or supposed victimhood status.  

Takeaways

  • People act as they believe (i.e. their worldview).
  • A worldview is how a person, or even a culture, views reality and their place in it.
  • Influences from entertainment, government, media, and education have a strong impact.
  • Worldviews are best developed in relationships with others, where honest questions can be asked and answered.  

Recommended Resources






Sunday, September 22, 2024

Apologetics 101 - Christian Case-Making - What is truth?

 

Christian Case-Making
in a Modern World

Apologetics 101

What is Truth?

Pilate once infamously asked the question, "What is truth?"  Is truth something that can objectively be known, or is it just in the eye of the beholder?  Is truth "out there", or are individuals free to make their own truths?  Can "my truth" and "my lived experience" carry more weight than inconvenient objective truths, even if my feelings and desires lead me to conclude otherwise?

We should want to believe truth and not falsehoods, so when we are learning to defend our faith (Apologetics), it makes sense that we should first determine if what we believe is true.  

Objective vs. Subjective Truth

Objective truth is much more than a person's opinion, and is no less than that which corresponds to reality.  The kind of truth that includes actual events, actions taken, and evidential facts is known as Objective Truth.  It is true no matter who believes it or not, since the reality of it exists independently of the observer.  Objective Truth can be investigated, tested, and verified (such as by the scientific method or logic). 

Another kind of truth that is commonly used today is Subjective Truth.  This kind of truth is based on a person's beliefs, views, feelings, or experiences, and can vary greatly between individuals or cultures.  But truth is not determined by claimed motivations, or whether one thinks something is good or evil.  While we can argue about the best flavor or ice cream (obviously chocolate chip mint), or who we feel was the GOAT in a certain sport, it really just comes down to personal preference.  There is not necessarily any correspondence to reality.  Claiming that "my truth", "your truth", or "my lived experience" is binding upon others is not a valid truth claim, because only The Truth actually exists. 

Sometimes the term Absolute Truth is used, but strategically objective truth is a much better term, since it makes a contrast with subjective truth and is less prone to confusion.  Absolute Truth can be confusing to people without careful qualification, for instance, “It’s absolutely wrong to lie.”  Does that mean that it is never okay to lie, or is there an underlying more general moral principle than needs to be unpacked?  For clarity, it is better to avoid the term.

Now truth claims can be wrong or mistaken, and false beliefs can and should be evaluated, and re-aligned with reality when necessary.  Knowledge is justified true belief.  Belief alone does not make something true, even if you are sincere.  The goal should be to align our beliefs so that they correspond to reality, since subjective truth is a poor foundation for important beliefs.

Related to subjective truth is the belief in Relativism.  Relativism has been aptly called having one's feet firmly planted in mid-air, since it has no philosophical grounding.  It is based on the idea that no objective truth exists, or certainly none that can be known. Relativistic morality is incoherent, and is ultimately logically self-defeating.  Without grounding, nothing can actually be called good or evil, only preferences.  It has no solid grounding for its claims, nor does it have the ability to assert claims of right or wrong, including its own truth claims.  For example, the Nazis believed that they were right to exterminate the undesirables, and with relativism, there are no objective grounds for disputing that.  It is not good enough to say that "I don't like that" or "I think that was wrong".  Without an objective moral standard, such as the uncaused creator God, relativism and subjective truths remain just the flavor of the day.    

Examples

  • It is okay to steal if you really need it. (S)

  • A man named Jesus lived in Judea about 2000 years ago, and was crucified by the Romans. (O)

  • My wife is the best wife in the whole world! (S)

  • The nature of human procreation is the combination of the sex gametes of a male and a female. (O)

  • Modern art is inspiring. (S)

  • Physics is the best and highest scientific discipline. (S)

  • No physical object can travel faster than the speed of light in a vacuum. (O)

  • Gender is closely related to biology, so it is unfair for trans-athletes to compete in sports against people of the opposite biological sex. (S)

  • Sex/gender are determined by biology, and not by a doctor's opinion or a person's feelings. (O)

  • It is wrong to torture babies just for the fun of it. (O)

Discovering Truth

Truth is something we should all seek.  It can be discovered or known.  Unlike the Postmodern worldview, the Christian worldview holds that reality is "out there", and that truth is not simply relative to the person and that it is knowable.  That does not mean, however, that we can exhaustively know everything, even if it is theoretically knowable.  And we can actually come to wrong conclusions, and be wrong, so humility is required too.

Before you start your search for Truth, you should ask yourself whether or not you are willing to follow the evidence wherever it leads.   If your biases are such that you will reject the evidence or refuse to give honest consideration to the facts, then you might as well not bother.  Regardless of their starting worldview, the truth seeker will at least consider the evidence from the viewpoint of those holding opposing views.  Willful ignorance or stubborn insistence on being "right" will be a stumbling block to the search for truth. 


When seeking the truth, if there are multiple independent sources of information supporting claims, then we have a higher confidence in our conclusions.   From investigating the reliability of the New Testament accounts and the Resurrection, to claims in a highly-charged political environment, there are some principles to apply:
  • Eyewitness testimony (both friendly and hostile) of conversations, events, experiences, and actions are valuable. 

  • The truth-seeker considers historical records, financial documents, email/text trails, business associates' testimony, and contemporaneous recorded or documented conversations.

  • Statements from experts or officials with firsthand information should be given more weight than uninformed opinions of commentators.

  • Public statements, whether inconsistent, deliberate, or incidental, are all part of the puzzle to give serious consideration. 

  • Consideration of motives and biases of the participants is often used during investigations.  

  • Is there evidence of a cover up or conspiracy?  Are the participants holding together, or is it falling apart with defectors or leaks?

  • Allegations and opinions can be considered, but need to be given appropriate weight compared to the evidence.   These are either consistent with the evidence, or they may not be consistent.

In the end, we are looking for the best explanation of all the evidence (abductive reasoning).  Explanations which are coherent and consistent with the evidence should be given more credence. 

Knowing the Truth

From a Christian worldview perspective, there is a difference between just recognizing the truth, and actually embracing it.  The foundational truth is that God cannot lie and that He is the author of all Truth, so we have a reason to trust Him and the things He has revealed to us.  He can never contradict Himself, since He is the immutably good, all powerful, and necessary being.  Anything we discover to be truth can therefore be embraced, since "All Truths are God's Truths".
The CIA headquarters has the following line inscribed on the marble wall in their lobby,
  "And ye shall know the truth and the truth shall make you free."


Perhaps surprising to some is that this is a partial verse from the Bible, but it is really taken out of context.  The quotation from Jesus is, 


31 To the Jews who had believed him, Jesus said, “If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. 32 Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” 33 They answered him, “We are Abraham’s descendants and have never been slaves of anyone. How can you say that we shall be set free?” 34 Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, everyone who sins is a slave to sin. 35 Now a slave has no permanent place in the family, but a son belongs to it forever. 36 So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.  (John 8:31-34)


The Bible is clear that wisdom comes from acknowledging God as the source of Truth, not ourselves.


9 Instruct the wise and they will be wiser still;

    teach the righteous and they will add to their learning.

10 The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom,

    and knowledge of the Holy One is understanding.  (Proverbs 9:9-11)

and

When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth, for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come. (John 16:13)

 

When we acknowledge God first and choose to follow His Son, then we will know the truth, and then we will truly be free.  We never have to choose between having a love for studying the amazing creation that God has given us and loving God with all our hearts and minds. 

Takeaways

  • Truth corresponding to reality exists, and it is discoverable and knowable.

  • Objective truth is superior to subjective/relativistic truth.

  • Christians are called to know the truth, not just acknowledge it.  Then we are set free.

  • All Truth is God's Truth


More Apologetics Topics


Wednesday, July 31, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 31 - Celebrate Truth, All the Time. All the Time, Celebrate Truth

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 31 -  Celebrate Truth, All the Time.  All the Time, Celebrate Truth

It is not currently popular to stand for the truth.  Relativism reigns and new destructive philosophies such as CRT, DEI, and radical social justice vie for dominance against traditional values.  Words are redefined to win arguments and influence morality without firing a shot.  Feelings and desires are now said to define reality, and rights are granted and revoked as the powerful find useful.  "My truth" and "my lived experience" carry far more weight than inconvenient objective truths.


All is not lost, but it all starts with YOU.  Don't give in to redefinitions of truth and what is good/evil.  Question their assumptions and ask them how they justify their claims, or how they came to their conclusions.  Refuse to use their language and the Orwellian Newspeak they use. 


I would encourage everyone to not just embrace real truth for a limited time, but rather to incorporate it into your core values and promote it daily.


Tuesday, July 30, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 30 - Before passing judgment, be sure to apply the same standard to yourself

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 30 - Before passing judgment, be sure to apply the same standard to yourself

A common misconception among non-Christians, and even many church goers, is that we are commanded to never judge others.  Aren't we all just supposed to love and accept everyone as they are?  Well, that is not really what Jesus taught at all.


Here is what he actually said, 


1 “Do not judge, or you too will be judged. 2 For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.

3 “Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? 4 How can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? 5 You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.  (Matt. 7:1-5)


In context, it sure sounds like he actually expected us to make judgements, but called his followers to not be hypocritical about it.  Scripture is filled with examples and admonitions to make spiritual judgements about many things.  The actions and beliefs of others are fair game.  Of course, this is not a license to seek and destroy people's lives by pointing out every flaw one can find, regardless of how that will affect them.  The Bible is also very clear that we need to correct, rebuke, and teach others in such a way as to build them up or to restore them to fellowship.  It is never to be done to intentionally harm someone or to just win an argument.


Thursday, July 18, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 18 - Good and Evil both exist. Fight for good. Resist evil. (Ethics - Do the greater good)

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 18 - Good and Evil both exist. Fight for good. Resist evil. (Ethics - Do the greater good)

A principle in ethics is "Choose to do the greater good."  Sometimes this is recast as "Choose the lesser of two evils."  Regardless, our responsibility is to first identify good and evil, and then to work toward the former and against the latter.  


For most people, it is obvious that some form of evil exists.  But what defines evil and does it actually exist?  For real evil to exist, there must be an objective standard by which to judge it.  Relativism has a hard time with calling anything evil, since it is just the subjective opinion of the individual, group, or culture.  An individual may even belong to different groups with different moral standards.  Take this example, “Terrorists like to kill people; I like to save them."  Now who’s to say which is better… and more importantly how does the relativist make a determination that is more than just their preference or opinion?  Perhaps they just deny that objective standards exist by which to determine right and wrong, truth and falsehood.


In reality, we can't define good and evil on our own, but we can recognize it because we have a moral intuition that is built into our nature.  We know in our core that evil is real, and that it is something to be opposed and fought.  There is a way to ground morality, and that is in the morally perfect Creator who is the standard.


Sunday, July 14, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 14 - All people have dignity and worth, but not all actions and beliefs are true or good

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 14 -  All people have dignity and worth, but not all actions and beliefs are true or good.

Most people would agree that all people have dignity and worth.  The Christian worldview grounds this belief in the fact that we are created in the Image of God, and thus have inherent value.  However, it is a fallacy to assume that because of this status, criticizing the actions of a person or challenging their deeply held beliefs is out of bounds.


So what is good or evil?  Intuitively, we know that all beliefs and cultures are not necessarily good or true, or at least some are better than others (e.g. cannibalism, torture of babies).  But only a worldview that holds to objective morality has the grounding to justify calling something good or evil, right or wrong.  Cultures that hold to relativistic morality lose the ability to fairly criticize others, since they have no objective basis to claim their views are morally superior.  In fact, relativism results in moral claims becoming just preferences (e.g. "I don't like that").  


For example, given relativistic morality, one can't claim that slavery is actually wrong, since slave owners can just as easily claim that it is right.  The most that can be claimed is "I believe that you are wrong and I'd prefer that you don't do it".  The problem is that we all actually have a moral intuition that tells us that it is wrong.  The Christian worldview explains this insight as a reflection of the Image of God in all of us.  Relativism fails to have that explanatory power.


Saturday, July 13, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 13 - All Truth is God's Truth

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 13 - All Truth is God's Truth

Truth is what corresponds to reality.  It is not about what we feel, or determined by strongly held convictions.  The foundational truth is that God cannot lie and that He is the author of all Truth.  He can never contradict Himself, since He is the immutably good, all powerful, and necessary being.


Christians have often struggled with change.  The enlightenment which fostered the scientific revolution has been hard for some to accept, especially when there are apparent discrepancies between the Words of Scripture and the discoveries of modern science.  Who do we believe and where do we place our trust?  Do we really have to choose between believing in God and facts discovered by the scientific method?


Fortunately, there is a third option — the realization that "All Truth is God's Truth."   The God who created the whole natural realm and then chose to reveal Himself to us cannot, and will not, deceive us or communicate falsehoods.  God did not give us evidence of a past history that never happened, nor did He give His revelation to mislead us into believing falsehoods.  


Historically, Christians have held to a concept called "dual revelation", or the two Books view, which is well articulated by the Belgic Confession of 1561: 


We know him by two means: first, by the creation, preservation and government of the universe; which is before our eyes as a most elegant book, wherein all creatures, great and small, are as so many characters leading us to contemplate the invisible things of God, namely, his power and divinity, as the apostle Paul saith, Romans 1:20. All which things are sufficient to convince men, and leave them without excuse. Secondly, he makes himself more clearly and fully known to us by his holy and divine Word, that is to say, as far as is necessary for us to know in this life, to his glory and our salvation.


Because both revelations come from the Creator God, there can be no inherent conflict between truths found in each.  However, we need to be humble enough to realize that, as human beings, we can misinterpret one or both, and force a seeming conflict or contradiction.  Also, it is possible that we simply don't yet fully understand portions well enough to be dogmatic about certain particulars.  


The TLDR bottom line is this:  We do not have to choose between having a love for studying the amazing creation that God has given us and loving God with all our hearts and minds.  


Friday, July 12, 2024

Truth Month - July 2024 - Day 12 - To Know the Truth, Jesus said to first Follow and Obey him

 

Truth Month - July 2024


Day 12 - To Know the Truth, Jesus said to first Follow and Obey him

The CIA headquarters has the following line inscribed on the marble wall in their lobby,


  "And ye shall know the truth and the truth shall make you free."


Perhaps surprising to some is that this is a partial verse from the Bible, but it is really taken out of context.  The quotation from Jesus is, 


31 To the Jews who had believed him, Jesus said, “If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. 32 Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”

33 They answered him, “We are Abraham’s descendants and have never been slaves of anyone. How can you say that we shall be set free?”

34 Jesus replied, “Very truly I tell you, everyone who sins is a slave to sin. 35 Now a slave has no permanent place in the family, but a son belongs to it forever. 36 So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.  (John 8:31-34)


The Bible is clear that wisdom comes from acknowledging God as the source of Truth, not ourselves.


9 Instruct the wise and they will be wiser still;

    teach the righteous and they will add to their learning.

10 The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom,

    and knowledge of the Holy One is understanding.  (Proverbs 9:9-11)


and

When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth, for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come. (John 16:13)

 

In reality, truth can be a burden.  But when we acknowledge God first and choose to follow His Son, then we will truly be free.